In 1971, Urie Bronfenbrenner’s work, Two Worlds of Childhood, was published. I know nothing about it beyond this one quote in The Well-Trained Mind, by Susan Wise Bauer. In light of the incidents of kids shooting kids in schools, I think this man’s work perhaps deserves a closer look. Here’s what he says, with SWB’s words in regular print, his in bold.
Thirty years ago, Cornell Professor of Child Development Urie Bronfenbrenner warned that the “socially-isolated, age-graded peer group” created a damaging dependency in which middle-school students relied on their classmates for approval, direction, and affection. He warned that if parents, other delights, and older children continued to be absent from the daily life of younger children, we could expect “alienation, indifference, antagonism, and violence on the part of the younger generation.”
Interesting.
The Well-Trained Mind has a nice chapter on the question, “But what about socialization?” If you even mention, in a crowd of people who are not familiar with it, the idea of teaching kids at home, this will come up. If you’re like me, at first you’ll launch into a list of ways you personally make sure your child has plenty of chances to interact with peers: church, sports, home school group events. In other words, I bought into the idea that by not putting my child in school, I was depriving him of something necessary to his complete development. After reading this chapter a few times (at least it took me a few times for it to soak in), you’ll understand that this is simply not true. Your family is arguably the best, at the very least an appropriate, social setting for your children, and better prepares them for life in “the real world” than a classroom can.
By the way, in case you’re curious, William Golding’s novel Lord of the Flies came out in 1954.




